As soon as I came across this photo of Lucy Liu in a black and white floral print (from Giambattista Valli's Fall 2011 collection), I knew I'd seen it before.

"Marie Claire" director and "Project Runway" judge Nina Garcia was the first to wear the fine china-esque print, different cabinet of a dress, on the "Project Runway" set back in June.

While each fashionista styled her dress to suit the season in which it was worn, Lucy's shoulder pillows pack a little too much punch, so I'm going to give this to Nina.

Which style is the right way, and which one needs to hit the highway? You tell me in the comment section below.

Photos (left to right): Andrew H. Walker/WireImage for Tory Burch; Richie Buxo/Splash News