Singers Estelle and Corinne Bailey Rae both have similar (split) style personalities!

Estelle belted up her red and black Alice + Olivia jersey maxi for Us Weekly's 25 Most Stylish New Yorkers of 2011 event recently in New York.

Just four days earlier, Corinne Bailey took a more casual approach to the same colorblocked style (save for the red) at a celebration for Christian Siriano's Spring Summer Collection 2012 in the same city.

While I could totally see myself rocking Corinne's downtown-chic look for a more casual/artsy affair, there's no denying Estelle worked the heck out of her dress, so I'm giving her a higher score with a little help from the diva curve.

Which style is the right way, and which one needs to hit the highway? You tell me in the comment section below.

Photos (left to right): Desiree Navarro/Getty Images; Henry S. Dziekan III/Stringer/Getty Images