As Riley (Jennifer Love Hewitt) attempts to let Kyle back into her life (Brian Hallisay), Lacey (Rebecca Field) struggles to show her support. Kyle turns to Dale (Greg Grunberg) to help him find a job. Meanwhile, Joey (J.R. Cacia), an ex from Selena's (Alicia Lagano) past, shows up with a shocking demand and Riley, Derek (Rob Mayes), and Nikki (Laura Leigh) step in to help. Riley also asks advice from her sexy client, Victor (Matt Cohen), who is a former lawyer. Evan (Colin Egglesfield) and Shelby (T.V. Carpio) prepare for their graduation from the Academy.