Season 1, Episode 5 - "Project Runway All Stars" Season 1 Episode 5 (Clothes Off Your Back). Air Date: 2/2/2012. The All Stars take to the streets of New York to convince total strangers to part with their clothes in the name of fashion. Their muse's outfits are ripped apart and reborn in the hands of an All Star. Guest judge is NHL star Sean Avery.