Season 1, Episode 12 - Watch bonus footage of runway judging of Austin Scarlett from "Project Runway All Stars" Season 1 Episode 12. The moment of truth arrives for three final All Stars as they present their signature collections to a VIP Runway show crowd. Who will claim the biggest prize in Runway history and be crowned the first "Project Runway All Stars" winner? Guest judges are fashion icon Tommy Hilfiger and fashion director of Neiman Marcus Ken Downing. Episode air date: 3/22/2012.